When the safety net snaps: Family homelessness, collective survival, and the winter ahead in Alachua County

by Leigh Scott, Director of Community Engagement, Family Promise of Gainesville

Seven months ago, when St. Francis House shuttered its doors, a tremor ran through Alachua County’s social safety net. 

For decades, local residents were accustomed to the idea — however strained — that an institutional buffer existed for parents and children who lost their housing. But when that door locked for good, the buffer vanished. 

Overnight, Family Promise of Gainesville was left as the sole full-time agency addressing family homelessness in our community. Fortunately, we stood up to get 8 of the families being exited from Saint Francis house into housing… But that left hundreds more with nowhere to go.

Let’s be clear about why we are in this mess. 

We have spent the last two decades building Gainesville for the students and left everyone else out of the equation from working class single parents, rural Alachua County communities, the east side and people of color have all been left out of the conversation. 

We have a raging debate every time we talk about affordable housing. “What is affordable housing? Is it an affordable new home? Where should we build it? Why are we concentrating all the poverty on the east side? “

These are all the questions that come up when we talk about affordable housing. When it comes to luxury student living … Those apartments go up overnight crushing landmarks like Leo’s or affordable two-bedroom homes on 5th Ave. We never debate those. They just get built.

There’s no way for us to dress this up … We’re at DEFCON five when it comes to family homelessness.

According to the school district’s McKinney-Vento data, more than 1,000 public school students and their family members in Alachua County are experiencing homelessness.

These are not abstract statistics. 

They are third-graders trying to finish homework in the backseat of a sedan parked under the glaring lights of a Walmart parking lot. 

They are parents working 50 hours a week at service jobs at LESS than living wages across Gainesville, watching every dollar swallowed by skyrocketing rents, medical debt, and grocery bills, only to find themselves one broken transmission away from sleeping in a tent off Hawthorne Road or a cheap unsafe motel room

Across Florida and the country, we are witnessing the cascading collapse of safety net systems under the weight of ideological austerity. From aggressive legislative attacks on (DEI) initiatives that have gutted vital institutional support pipelines or the ability to report vital social determinants of health data, to the clawbacks and deregulation promised under federal initiatives like DOGE, to the cascading fiscal aftermath of state constitutional shifts like Amendment 3, public resources for human needs are being strangled. Municipalities and service providers are being forced to do the impossible: absorb surging poverty with evaporating funds, while public policy criminalizes they very people we are trying to serve.

In Alachua County, where we pride ourselves on community consciousness and solidarity, we have to ask ourselves: What happens when the institutional safety net completely snaps? We now know the answer to that after the closing of St. Francis House.

We catch each other, or no one does.

Family Promise has been anchored in this community since 1998, originally founded as the Interfaith Hospitality Network. For over two decades, our model relied on a deeply communal, rotational network of faith communities. 

Thirteen local congregations across Gainesville would open their fellowship halls and classrooms, taking turns hosting four families at a time for one week each. In turn our staff would get them housed. Our families stay housed after 1-year, 95% of the time because we continue to work with them once they are housed.

Then came COVID-19.

In the wake of that rupture, we worked to build a more permanent anchor. We acquired and began renovating The Promise Center, located off North 13th Street. When fully realized, this center will safely shelter nine families at a time, including two fully accessible units specifically designed for parents or children living with disabilities. But major structural renovations take time, capital, and permits—and winter waits for none of those things.

Hoping to revive the rotational shelter model to meet this year’s surging crisis, we spent months reaching out to dozens of congregations across the county. 

The goodwill was palpable; nearly everyone we spoke with expressed a desire to help. But when we convened an emergency interfaith summit to secure hard commitments, the hard realities of congregations, insurance constraints, and limited volunteer bases set in: only four churches were able to commit fully to opening their physical doors to host families. 

Four weeks out of a twelve-week cycle cannot sustain a family through to permanent housing.

With cold weather descending on North Central Florida, we cannot afford to wait for ideal conditions. We have had to pivot quickly.

When freezing temperatures strike Gainesville, parents with children under 18 face unthinkable choices. We want to prevent families from freezing in cars and encampments.

We have found the space. A downtown church has generously stepped forward, offering to lease an attached school building that was recently vacated. The facility is secure, centrally located, and well-suited to provide dignity and warmth to unhoused families when the thermometer drops below freezing.

Now, the burden of execution falls directly on our community.

Family Promise operates with a core staff of just eight people. Every one of us works relentless hours, but eight people cannot run emergency intake, manage casework, maintain regular shelter operations, and staff an overnight cold-weather facility alone. We need the progressive community of Gainesville to mobilize with us:

The Meal Brigade: We need community members, neighborhood groups, and student collectives willing to prepare hearty, freezable meals — a pan of lasagna or a bagged lunch or a nutritious casserole — label them, freeze them, and deliver them so our overnight staff can simply heat and serve warm food when cold night shelter is called.

Overnight and Evening Volunteers: We need compassionate, reliable volunteers willing to undergo rapid training to assist with evening hospitality, family check-in, keeping watch overnight

Financial Solidarity: We need grassroots contributions to bridge the funding gap so that lack of cash does not leave a six-year-old out in the frost.

If you have a freezer to store a meal, an evening to give, or resources to contribute to our Promise fund, step forward now. Visit our website at familypromisegainesville.org to learn more, or email our Director of Community Engagement, Leigh Scott, directly at leigh@familypromisegainesville.org.

Let us ensure that when winter arrives, no family is left out in the cold.

Comments are closed.